[tp widget="default/tpw_default.php"]

did trump propose cuts to social security

did trump propose cuts to social security插图

Are Trump’s proposed Social Security cuts coming in 2020?

Proposed Social Security cuts once again came to issue in January 2020 following Trump’s tweet. In addition, around the same time, Trump said he was “open” to Social Security cuts. In response, O’Brien and others pointed to Trump’s proposed FY2020 Budget.

Did Trump propose a cut to Social Security benefits for disabled veterans?

On page 225, Johnston wrote that: The biggest cut Trump proposed [in his 2018 budget] was ending a benefit for disabled veterans once they reach the minimum age for Social Security benefits. These veterans would see their income plunge from almost $35,000 annually to less than $13,000 if the Trump plan becomes law.

Does Donald Trump want to destroy Social Security?

In the press release, the group’s president Nancy Altman wrote: Donald Trump once promised that he would be ‘the only Republican that doesn’t want to cut Social Security.’ We now know that what he meant is that cutting Social Security doesn’t go far enough for him: He wants to destroy Social Security.

Will the President cut Social Security benefits?

“The president has argued against any Social Security benefit cuts but hasn’t waded into how Social Security’s long-term funding should be secured.”

What is the payroll tax cut for Social Security?

The 12.4% payroll tax on earned income (wages and salary, but not investment income) was responsible for $944.5 billion of the $1.06 trillion that Social Security collected in 2019.

How much will Social Security spend in the next 10 years?

According to estimates, Social Security is estimated to expend more than $15 trillion, in aggregate, over the next 10 years. This means a $24 billion to $72 billion outlay reduction to resolve perceived inefficiencies in the SSDI program represents a mere fraction of total outlays.

How long is Social Security unfunded?

Since 1985, the annually released Social Security Board of Trustees report has cautioned that the program’s long-term (75-year) outlays wouldn’t cover projected revenue collection. As of 2020, Social Security’s unfunded obligations through 2094 had ballooned to a whopping $16.8 trillion.

What is the call for testing?

A call for means testing. Another pathway to Social Security benefit cuts, loosely proposed by President Trump while on the campaign trail four years ago, is means testing, which would partially or fully phase-out benefits for individuals who earn more than preset income thresholds.

When will Trump defer payroll tax?

In an effort to combat the economic struggles tied to the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, Trump signed an executive order in mid-August that deferred payroll tax collection between Sept. 1 and Dec. 31.

How much will Social Security be cut in 2035?

Without intervention from Capitol Hill, retired workers could face sweeping benefit cuts of up to 24%, beginning in 2035. There’s no question Social Security needs some help, and that’s expected to start at the top, with President Trump.

How many people are on Social Security?

Social Security, our nation’s most prized social program, is responsible for providing benefits to over 46 million retired workers each month and is singlehandedly pulling more than 15 million of those retirees out of poverty. It’s also a program that’s in some pretty big trouble.

What did Trump say about the payroll tax?

First, he said he planned to “forgive” the payroll taxes in question, meaning that rather than simply being delayed, the obligation to pay those four months’ worth of Social Security and Medicare taxes would be removed entirely.

What is OASDI in Social Security?

Doing so would remove the overwhelming majority of funding for the two benefits that comprise Social Security: Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI), and Disability Insurance (DI), known collectively as OASDI. According to the federal Social Security Administration, fully 89% of OASDI came from payroll taxes in 2019.

How much do you pay for payroll taxes?

For Social Security, an employer and employee each pay the equivalent of 6.2% of the employee’s wages (12.4% in total), while for Medicare, the employer and employee each pay 1.45% (2.9% in total). Self-employed workers pay all 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare themselves.

When will the President extend the payroll tax deferral?

However, the president made additional remarks that were not contained in the memorandum itself, indicating that he intended to extend that deferral beyond Dec. 31, 2020; to waive any later obligation on employees to pay the deferred contributions; and even that he planned to eliminate payroll taxes entirely. The following is an edited transcript of the relevant section of his remarks. (A full transcript of his press conference is available here, and his remarks can be viewed in full below.)

When will Social Security taxes be eliminated?

On Aug. 8, 2020, U.S. President Donald Trump said he intended to "terminate the tax," referring to Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes. It’s a step that would — if taken in isolation — remove nearly 90% of funding for Social Security benefits, and thus likely pose a threat to the continued existence of those programs.

Is it reasonable to remove Social Security funding?

It is reasonable to suppose that removing so much funding for Social Security, without replacing it, would pose a threat to the continued existence of Social Security itself and its associated OASDI benefits. In his Aug. 8 remarks, Trump made no reference to a plan for replacing the funding that would be lost if he carried out his stated intention to terminate payroll taxes, nor has he done so anywhere else. (Snopes asked the White House and the Trump campaign to provide details on how the president intends to cover the shortfall in Social Security funding, but we did not receive a substantive response from either.)

Did Trump cancel Social Security?

Trump did not explicitly vow to terminate Social Security, as those headlines claimed, but one of several plans he mentioned in an Aug. 8 press conference involved eliminating payroll taxes — a move that would, as things stand, remove the overwhelming majority of funding for Social Security and likely pose a threat to its continued existence.

What is the Biden campaign’s claim about Social Security?

The Biden camp justifies its claims about President Trump’s “proposed cuts” to Social Security by pointing to the Trump administration’s recent efforts to implement a payroll tax holiday as part of the ongoing efforts to blunt the economic impact of Covid-19.

Why is politics ain’t beanbag?

The cliche “politics ain’t beanbag” exists for a reason: Campaigns use overhyped rhetoric to distort their opponent’s positions and make them appear less electable. Seniors should rest easy and understand that their Social Security benefits aren’t going anywhere.

When will Social Security run dry?

At the end of August, the chief actuary at the Social Security Administration penned a letter saying that removing payroll taxes would cause funding for Social Security to run dry by the middle of 2023.

What does confidence mean in politics?

Confidence not only means avoiding spurious campaign claims but also having political leaders demonstrate that they understand how critical Social Security is to the lives of seniors across the country . Hopefully, Washington will get the message before it’s too late. Follow me on Twitter .

Did Trump support payroll tax?

While Trump has talked fast and loose about nixing the payroll tax, he has also said he’d support replacing that revenue with money from the government’s general fund. And for the record, President Trump hasn’t supported actual legislation that would change how Social Security is funded.

Does payroll tax help Social Security?

Payroll taxes help fund Social Security, but they are not synonymous with the program. In August, the CARES Act’s supplemental $600 weekly unemployment benefit ran out. Negotiations for a second stimulus package among the White House, the House Democrats and the Senate Republicans were going nowhere fast.

Did the 600 unemployment run out?

In August, the CARES Act’s supplemental $600 week ly unemployment benefit ran out. Negotiations for a second stimulus package among the White House, the House Democrats and the Senate Republicans were going nowhere fast. In response to the deadlock in Congress, President Trump enacted a payroll tax holiday by executive order.

How much will the defense budget increase in 2020?

Under the deal, defense spending will increase roughly 3 percent over current levels and nondefense spending will go up around 4 percent.

How much money did Trump cut from Medicare?

At a time of massive wealth and income inequality, Trump’s budget pays for his huge tax break to the top one percent by cutting $1.5 trillion from Medicaid, $845 billion from Medicare and $25 billion from Social Security. Make no mistake about it: Trump’s budget is a massive transfer of wealth from working class families to the wealthiest people and most profitable corporations in America.

How much will Social Security be cut in 2020?

Upon the release of Trump’s proposed 2020 Budget for Fiscal Year 2020 (which began in October 2019), $25 billion in cuts to Social Security over ten years was a factor widely reported:

What is the presidential budget?

To begin with, presidential budgets are often a rough draft from which Congress begins pushing and pulling to fit certain fiscal and political agendas. Or, in plain English, it’s a starting point from which discussion begins, not a final draft. By the time a federal spending bill has been signed into law, it often looks nothing like the annual budget or 10-year projections presented months earlier by the president.

When did O’Brien tweet 2020?

O’Brien retweeted a January 23 2020 tweet from the President, in which he said:

When is the deadline for budget approval?

The hard deadline for budget approval is September 30. If Congress doesn’t approve it by then, the government can shut down. It did just that in 2013, January 2018, and in December 2018. To avoid shutdowns, Congress usually passes continuing resolutions.

When does Congress have to approve a budget?

The executive branch then has the ability to respond, and Congress has until September 30th to approve a budget for the fiscal year (which begins on October 1st) to avoid a government shutdown:

How will the payroll tax cut affect Social Security?

Cutting Social Security taxes from September through December would hurt Social Security’s finances; permanently eliminating the tax would gut the program. Trump’s proposed payroll tax cut would eliminate about 35 percent to 45 percent of Social Security payroll tax revenue, depending on details not yet known.** This would drain about $350–$450 billion in payroll tax revenue in 2021 and more in later years. This enormous revenue loss would greatly accelerate the exhaustion of the trust fund. Once the trust fund is exhausted, remaining Social Security revenues would fund only a portion of promised benefits, which are already modest. The average monthly benefit for retired workers is now $1,516. The average monthly benefit for disabled workers is $1,259.

How is Social Security funded?

Social Security is funded by a 6.2 percent payroll tax paid both by employees and employers; this payroll tax goes into the Social Security trust fund.* According to the trustees’ latest projections, the trust fund ensures that Social Security beneficiaries can count on all of their promised benefits until 2035, giving Congress enough time to address Social Security’s longer-term financial shortfall. Currently, 65 million people receive Social Security benefits, including retirees, people with disabilities, widows and widowers, and surviving spouses and children of workers. Most seniors and disabled worker beneficiaries rely on Social Security for a majority of their income. As the pandemic continues to exact a toll on Americans’ health and financial security, Social Security’s guaranteed income is all the more important.

Will the trust fund be exhausted in 2025?

Under an alternate assumption of Trump’s policy—permanently eliminating the tax for wages under that threshold, including for workers earning more—the combined trust fund would be exhausted in 2025. With the trust fund exhausted, remaining revenues would only be able to pay for 50 percent of promised benefits, declining over time. For an average earner who retires at the age of 65, a 50 percent benefit cut in 2025 would be a loss of $859 per month, or $10,313 over a year, in today’s dollars.

Is American Progress independent?

The positions of American Progress, and our policy experts, are independent, and the findings and conclusions presented are those of American Progress alone. A full list of supporters is available here. American Progress would like to acknowledge the many generous supporters who make our work possible.

How much would Trump’s proposal affect veterans?

AMVETS estimated that Trump’s proposal would affect 225,000 military veterans aged over 65 and would decrease by a full $1,200 a month the disability benefit paid to an unmarried veteran with a 90 percent disabled rating.

What cuts did Trump propose?

The biggest cut Trump proposed [in his 2018 budget] was ending a benefit for disabled veterans once they reach the minimum age for Social Security benefits. These veterans would see their income plunge from almost $35,000 annually to less than $13,000 if the Trump plan becomes law.

What is the Trump budget proposal?

President Donald Trump’s 2018 budget proposal calls for cuts in benefits to highly disabled veterans.

How much disability do you need to be to qualify for IU?

In order to qualify for IU, a veteran must be assessed as being at least 60 percent disabled due to a service-connected disability or disabilities.

How much money did Trump save in 2018?

The Trump administration estimated that the proposed cuts would save $3.2 billion in 2018 and $40.8 billion over 10 years and had proposed using those savings to help fund a plan to expand and make permanent the Obama administration’s Veterans Choice Program , which seeks to improve the availability of care for veterans in their own communities.

What was Donald Trump’s campaign promise?

As a presidential candidate, one of Donald Trump’s main campaign promises was to improve the treatment of United States military veterans and initiate major reforms to the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). However, the president faced criticism during 2018 budget talks amidst reports that he was proposing significant cuts to benefits …

How much does a veteran get if they have 100 percent disability?

However, under individual unemployability, veterans are treated as if they had a disability rating of 100 percent, meaning they would receive $2,973.86 each month. For veterans eligible to receive Social Security, Trump’s plan would have pruned their monthly disability benefit back to the 60 percent rate, a highly significant cut of $1,890.34, …

Why did the deficit grow under Trump?

While the national deficit has grown under Trump, in part due to the president’s tax cuts and a two-year budget deal that increased spending, acting White House budget director Russ Vought touted the proposal as fiscally responsible and sought to shift blame to Congress for the deficit.

What is the budget for 2021?

The president spoke with governors from around the nation at the White House Monday. President Donald Trump unveiled a $4.8 trillion budget Monday that seeks to balance the budget in 15 years, falling short of the the traditional Republican target of doing so over 10 years.

What is the election year proposal?

The election-year proposal calls for reducing future spending to Medicaid, Medicare and other social safety programs. The reductions are designed to not directly impact recipients but, similar to last year’s proposal, aims to achieve savings by reforming how Medicare pays hospitals and health care providers.

Where is the 2021 budget printed?

Copies of President Donald Trump’s proposed budget for the U.S. Government for the 2021 Fiscal Year are printed at the Government Publishing Office, Feb. 6, 2020, in Washington, DC.

Did the President’s budget proposal pass Congress?

The president’s budget proposal is not expected to actually pass Congress but is seen as a blueprint for the administration’s priorities. Though the president pledged as a candidate not to cut Medicaid, Vought portrayed cuts in the budget as "saving" that amount to "good government reforms.".

What is an example of misleading information?

One example of misleading information is an Oct. 30 tweet by Really American, an anti-Trump political action committee, which released a digital ad attacking Trump’s position on the payroll tax. The video features Trump saying: “We’ll be terminating the payroll tax. This would be a fantastic time to have the payroll tax cut” and “We’re cutting the payroll tax.”

How much payroll tax is paid for Social Security?

THE FACTS: The payroll tax goes into a trust fund that pays for Social Security payments for roughly 65 million Americans. Employers and workers split paying the 12.4% payroll tax, and self-employed people pay the full tax. Medicare, the health insurance program for seniors, is funded by a 2.9% payroll tax. Medicaid, health insurance for low income people, is not funded from a payroll tax.

How long would it take for Social Security to be depleted?

The chief actuary for the Social Security Administration has saidthat if the payroll tax were to be eliminated, and no alternative source of revenue was created, the trust fund that pays for Social Security would be depleted in less than three years.

Is Medicaid funded by payroll tax?

Furthermore, Medicaid is not funded by the payroll tax, as the tweet suggests. It is true that Trump has supported measures that would scale back Medicaid.

Will Social Security run out in 2035?

Even before the coronavirus pandemic caused economic turmoil, government experts estimated that Social Security would be unable to pay full benefits starting in 2035, The Associated Press has reported. The trust fund is now likely to run out even sooner, because layoffs have cut into Social Security tax collections.

Related Post